458 East 51st Street
458 East 51st Street in East Flatbush, Brooklyn, has 32 open HPD violations, 14 of them class C, and 53 of 53 units are rent-stabilized, as of Oct 26, 2026. StreetSpy grade: D (51/100).
Multi-family elevator · 53 units · Built 1940
StreetSpy grade: D (Poor, 51/100)
- 14 immediately hazardous violations open (the class that covers no heat, pests, lead paint and similar).
- 1 open violation is classified rent-impairing under NY Multiple Dwelling Law section 302-a.
- 12 heat or hot water complaints to 311 in the last 12 months.
- 53 of 53 units are rent-stabilized.
More open violations per unit than 7 in 10 Brooklyn buildings this size.
- Repairs: High (32 open, 14 class C), records as of Oct 26, 2026
- Heat and hot water: 12 complaints, 12 mo, records as of Oct 25, 2026
- Pests: Clear (Owner reported none, 3 yr), records as of Oct 28, 2026
- Safety: Clear (No open DOB violations), records as of Oct 26, 2026
- Registration: Renewal not yet in city data, records as of Oct 3, 2026
Housing code violations (HPD)
32 open violations: 14 class C (immediately hazardous), 16 class B, 2 class A. 74 issued in the last 12 months. 932 on record. Oldest open violation issued 2017-10-10. Newest violation issued 2026-07-06.
62 closed in the last 90 days. Median 84 days from issue to close for the 104 violations closed in the last 12 months.
1 open violation is classified rent-impairing under NY Multiple Dwelling Law section 302-a. Section 302-a; NY Courts guidance on getting repairs.
- Class C: Self-closing door not working, 1st floor. , 27-2007, 27-2041.1 HMC, §238, § 309; § 107 (2) ( C) MDL AND 28 RCNY §25-171: REPLACE OR REPAIR THE SELF-CLOSING DOORS THAT IS MISSING OR DEFECTIVE HINGES AT DOOR IN THE ENTRANCE LOCATED AT APT A6, 1st STORY, 1st APARTMENT FROM WEST AT NORTH (apt A6), issued 2026-06-23. HPD violation 19023042
- Class C: Damaged plaster or paint, east wall, bathroom, 1st floor. REPLACE THE BROKEN OR DEFECTIVE WASH BASIN AT EAST WALL IN THE BATHROOM LOCATED AT APT A6, 1st STORY, 1st APARTMENT FROM WEST AT NORTH (apt A6), issued 2026-06-23. HPD violation 19023038
- Class C: Roaches, throughout the apartment, 1st floor. HMC ADM CODE: § 27-2017.4 ABATE THE INFESTATION CONSISTING OF ROACHES IN THE ENTIRE APARTMENT LOCATED AT APT A8, 1st STORY, 1st APARTMENT FROM NORTH AT EAST (apt A8), issued 2026-05-26. HPD violation 18949417
- Class C: Mice, throughout the apartment, 1st floor. HMC ADM CODE: § 27-2017.4 ABATE THE INFESTATION CONSISTING OF MICE IN THE ENTIRE APARTMENT LOCATED AT APT A8, 1st STORY, 1st APARTMENT FROM NORTH AT EAST (apt A8), issued 2026-05-26. HPD violation 18949418
- Class C: Lead paint hazard. - CORRECT FAILURE TO NOTIFY OCCUPANTS AND/OR TO INVESTIGATE LEAD-BASED PAINT HAZARDS., issued 2025-06-27. HPD violation 18053409
- Class C: Lead paint hazard. : CORRECT FAILURE TO PROVIDE TO THE DEPARTMENT WITHIN 45 DAYS OF DEMAND ALL RECORDS REQUIRED TO BE MAINTAINED BY OWNER PURSUANT TO LOCAL LAW 1 OF 2004 RELATED TO LEAD-BASED PAINT NOTICES, INSPECTIONS AND REMEDIATION/ABATEMENT ACTIVITIES., issued 2025-06-27. HPD violation 18053408
- Class C: Mice, throughout the apartment, 5th floor. HMC ADM CODE: § 27-2017.4 ABATE THE INFESTATION CONSISTING OF MICE IN THE ENTIRE APARTMENT LOCATED AT APT 3E, 5th STORY, 2nd APARTMENT FROM EAST AT SOUTH (apt 3E), issued 2025-03-26. HPD violation 17785756
- Class C: Mice, throughout the apartment, 4th floor. HMC ADM CODE: § 27-2017.4 ABATE THE INFESTATION CONSISTING OF MICE IN THE ENTIRE APARTMENT LOCATED AT APT D4, 4th STORY, 1st APARTMENT FROM SOUTH AT WEST (apt D4), issued 2025-02-21. HPD violation 17709784
311 housing complaints
29 in the last 12 months, 173 in 5 years. Most common: Heat/Hot Water (12), Unsanitary Condition (6), Paint/Plaster (5), Water Leak (4), Elevator (1).
Bedbugs
The owner reported 0 infested units in the last 3 years of filings. HPD's bedbug filings are self-reported by the owner once a year; HPD does not inspect to confirm them.
- 2026: No bedbug filing on record for this year
- 2025: Owner reported 0 infested units
- 2024: Owner reported 0 infested units
- 2023: Owner reported 0 infested units
- 2022: Owner reported 3 infested, 3 treated, 0 re-infested
- 2021: Owner reported 0 infested units
Buildings department (DOB)
No open DOB violations. 0 DOB violations on record. Check on DOB BIS.
Evictions and housing court
2 executed evictions in the last 3 years (12 on record). 0 open HPD cases; 0 harassment findings.
Rent stabilization
53 of 53 units rent-stabilized as of 2024. Stabilized renewals: 0% for one year and 0% for two years under RGB Order #58 (Oct 1, 2026 to Sep 30, 2027).
Rent-stabilized units on city tax bills: 53 in 2024, 53 in 2007. Source: DOF tax bills for 2007 and 2024; years with no bill on file are left out.
Owner and management
Owner: 458 East 51st Street Partners LLC. Head officer: Jay Silver. Managing agent: Jay Silver. This owner has 33 buildings on record, 29 graded D or F. See the full portfolio.
Last HPD registration Nov 21, 2025. Registration on file through Sep 1, 2026; renewal not yet in the city's data.
Tax lot and city IDs
BBL 3046980037, HPD building ID 267668. HPD Online, ACRIS, DOB BIS.
Nearest subway
- Saratoga Av (3), 21 min walk
- Church Av (2, 5), 21 min walk
- Sutter Av-Rutland Rd (3), 21 min walk
How the grade is calculated
| Factor | On record | Points |
|---|---|---|
| Open HPD violations | 32 open (14 class C, 16 class B, 2 class A). 1 rent-impairing | −32 |
| 311 housing complaints (12 mo) | 29 | −14 |
| Bedbug reports (3 yr) | None reported | 0 |
| Executed evictions (3 yr) | 2 | −3 |
| Housing litigation | No open cases | 0 |
| Open DOB violations | None | 0 |
Sources: NYC HPD Housing Maintenance Code Violations, NYC 311 Service Requests, NYC HPD Bedbug Reporting, NYC Marshal Evictions (DOI), NYC HPD Housing Litigations, NYC DOB Violations, NYC DOF tax bills (via JustFix Who Owns What portfolio API, v2), NYC HPD Property Registration. Methodology. Report generated 2026-10-28.