Worst buildings in Tompkinsville, Staten Island

251 Broad Street has the most open HPD violations per 10 units of any graded rental building with 6 or more units in Tompkinsville: 159 per 10 units, 159 open in all, 31 of them class C.

Graded rental buildings with 6 or more units, ranked by open NYC HPD housing code violations per 10 units, the same rule as the citywide list. Co-ops, condos and public housing (NYCHA) are left out. Only buildings with an HPD violation issued in the last 24 months or a 311 housing complaint in the last 12 are listed. Class C means immediately hazardous. Records as of Oct 26, 2026.

#	Address	Units	Open per 10 units	Open violations	Grade	Owner
1	251 Broad Street	10	159	159 (31 class C)	F	251 broad street realty corp
2	200 Victory Boulevard	16	68.1	109 (24 class C)	F	200 VICTORY BLVD REALTY CORP
3	91 Broad Street	6	66.7	40 (26 class C)	F	Not on file
4	76 Gordon Street	6	61.7	37 (4 class C)	F	BVA STAPELTON REALTY CORP
5	12 Court Street	8	46.3	37 (1 class C)	F	Mendra Realty Co Inc
6	55 Targee Street	6	41.7	25 (0 class C)	D	Not on file
7	281 Van Duzer Street	6	40	24 (24 class C)	F	Individual owner
8	696 Bay Street	6	33.3	20 (10 class C)	D	Individual owner
9	24 Norwood Avenue	7	31.4	22 (0 class C)	D	BAYWOOD REALTY LLC
10	85 Wright Street	8	28.8	23 (1 class C)	F	WRIGHT85 LLC
11	46 Broad Street	6	28.3	17 (0 class C)	C	Individual owner
12	55 Laurel Avenue	6	26.7	16 (2 class C)	C	55 Laurel LLC
13	37 Avon Place	16	26.3	42 (8 class C)	F	NICASTRO PROPERTIES LLC
14	29 Avon Place	17	20.6	35 (9 class C)	F	AVON PLACE REALTY LLC
15	30 Park Hill Court	36	16.1	58 (4 class C)	D	FAIRWAY RICHMOND PARTNERS LP
16	51 Coursen Place	30	14	42 (13 class C)	F	51 COURSEN LLC
17	31 Park Hill Lane	12	13.3	16 (2 class C)	C	FAIRWAY HOUSING ASSOC
18	10 Park Hill Avenue	70	13.3	93 (2 class C)	D	FAIRWAY RICHMOND PARTNERS LP
19	30 Kimberly Lane	108	12.6	136 (33 class C)	F	TOMPKINS COURT APTS LP
20	61 Thompson Street	10	12	12 (3 class C)	D	61 Thompson llc
21	93 Harrison Street	6	11.7	7 (0 class C)	C	Individual owner
22	220 Osgood Avenue	84	11	92 (26 class C)	F	220 OSGOOD LLC
23	166 Vanderbilt Avenue	20	9.5	19 (1 class C)	F	166 VANDERBILT AVENUE, LLC
24	195 Van Duzer Street	8	8.8	7 (0 class C)	B	HMA CAPITAL LLC
25	180 Broad Street	105	6.7	70 (32 class C)	D	STAPALETON SENIOR OWNERS LLC (City program owner (HDFC))
26	48 Tompkins Street	12	6.7	8 (8 class C)	C	48-56 TOMPKINS ST LLC
27	700 Bay Street	16	5.6	9 (3 class C)	C	Not on file
28	110 Canal Street	8	5	4 (4 class C)	C	Individual owner
29	533 Bay Street	67	4.8	32 (6 class C)	C	BAY STREET HOUSING LP (City program owner (HDFC))
30	45 Avon Place	18	4.4	8 (4 class C)	D	45 AVON HOLDINGS
31	360 Van Duzer Street	8	3.8	3 (0 class C)	D	VAN DUZER DEVELOPMENT LLC
32	411 Vanderbilt Avenue	17	3.5	6 (0 class C)	C	City program owner (HDFC)
33	40 Prospect Street	92	1.7	16 (3 class C)	B	BAY STREET OWNER LLC
34	27 Norwood Avenue	6	1.7	1 (1 class C)	A	NORWOOD AVENUE HOLDINGS LLC
35	31 Norwood Avenue	6	1.7	1 (0 class C)	A	Not on file
36	351 Van Duzer Street	7	1.4	1 (0 class C)	B	Not on file
37	475 Bay Street	270	1.1	31 (4 class C)	C	475 Bay Street LLC (City program owner (HDFC))
38	Navy Pier Court	467	0.2	8 (2 class C)	B	HOMEPORT 1 LLC
39	35 Gordon Street	65	0.2	1 (0 class C)	B	ST VINCENT'S HDFC INC. (City program owner (HDFC))

The full list for Tompkinsville, up to 100 buildings. Each row is the record, not a verdict.

More for Tompkinsville: rent-stabilized buildings, best buildings, heat complaints, and the Tompkinsville page.

Sources: NYC HPD housing maintenance code violations, HPD property registrations and housing litigation, 311 service requests, DOB violations, NYC Marshals evictions, and HPD bedbug filings from NYC Open Data, plus rent-stabilized unit counts from NYC Department of Finance tax bills. How grades work.