Worst buildings in West Brighton, Staten Island

390 Castleton Avenue has the most open HPD violations per 10 units of any graded rental building with 6 or more units in West Brighton: 52.5 per 10 units, 42 open in all, 15 of them class C.

Graded rental buildings with 6 or more units, ranked by open NYC HPD housing code violations per 10 units, the same rule as the citywide list. Co-ops, condos and public housing (NYCHA) are left out. Only buildings with an HPD violation issued in the last 24 months or a 311 housing complaint in the last 12 are listed. Class C means immediately hazardous. Records as of Oct 26, 2026.

#AddressUnitsOpen per 10 unitsOpen violationsGradeOwner
1390 Castleton Avenue852.542 (15 class C)F390 CASTLETON ASSOCIATES LLC
2480 Castleton Avenue103434 (2 class C)F480 CASTLETON LLC
3375 Sharon Avenue832.526 (5 class C)FNot on file
4395 Victory Boulevard173051 (9 class C)DIndividual owner
5362 Bement Avenue62515 (0 class C)CIndividual owner
6869 Forest Avenue923.321 (0 class C)DIndividual owner
711 Highland Avenue623.314 (0 class C)DVICTORY HIGHLAND LLC
8454 Van Duzer Street5220.2105 (31 class C)FVAN DUZER REVIVE LLC
9131 Silver Lake Road2419.647 (8 class C)DIndividual owner
10103 Waldron Avenue818.815 (0 class C)DNM-RM PROPERTIES LLC
11287 Victory Boulevard6159 (0 class C)CNot on file
12690 Castleton Avenue1412.117 (13 class C)FEOM 690 CASTLETON LLC
13177 Silver Lake Road1611.318 (5 class C)DIndividual owner
14509 Davis Avenue811.39 (2 class C)FNARROWS ROAD SOUTH LLC
15558 Castleton Avenue228.619 (0 class C)CCASTLETON ASSOCIATES LLC
164a Chester Place348.529 (4 class C)DCHESTER PLACE PARTNERSHIP LP
17961 Victory Boulevard1117.179 (8 class C)FSILVER LAKE ASSOCIATES LP
18608 Castleton Avenue24512 (0 class C)CCASTLETON ASSOCIATES LLC
19630 Victory Boulevard604.728 (13 class C)D630 VICTORY BLVD. OWNER LLC
20700 Victory Boulevard2284.6105 (37 class C)DNot on file
21101 Myrtle Avenue343.813 (0 class C)COLIVET-ST VINCENT'S HDFC INC. (City program owner (HDFC))
22290 Myrtle Avenue243.89 (1 class C)CCEKA 286 REALTY LLC
23650 Victory Boulevard613.622 (5 class C)D650 VICTORY BLVD OWNER LLC
2460 North Burgher Avenue2403.174 (30 class C)DMarkham Gardens LP
25105 Davis Avenue322.89 (1 class C)CSNUG HARBOR BARD-DAVID ASSOCIATES
26102 Bard Avenue342.69 (0 class C)BSnug Harbor Bard Davis Associates
27447 St Pauls Avenue92.22 (2 class C)CNot on file
2822 Arlo Road1651.829 (9 class C)BGRYMES HILL APARTMENTS DEL LLC
2986 Glenwood Avenue61.71 (1 class C)CPAPP/BLDG/REALTY CORP
30610 Victory Boulevard721.39 (3 class C)B610 VICTORY BLVD OWNER LLC
31800 Victory Boulevard150115 (2 class C)CSI Victory, LLC
32457 Victory Boulevard120.81 (0 class C)A457-459 victory blvd llc
3322 Howard Avenue2510.820 (7 class C)BGRYMES HILL APARTMENTS DEL LLC
34174 Castleton Avenue330.31 (0 class C)BSI CASTLETON LLC
351440 Richmond Terrace800.11 (0 class C)ANot on file

The full list for West Brighton, up to 100 buildings. Each row is the record, not a verdict.

More for West Brighton: rent-stabilized buildings, best buildings, heat complaints, and the West Brighton page.

Sources: NYC HPD housing maintenance code violations, HPD property registrations and housing litigation, 311 service requests, DOB violations, NYC Marshals evictions, and HPD bedbug filings from NYC Open Data, plus rent-stabilized unit counts from NYC Department of Finance tax bills. How grades work.